Welcome, pizza aficionados and food enthusiasts alike, to a gastronomic exploration of Pawleys Island's vibrant pizza culture. Nestled along the South Carolina coast, this charming town is not just a haven for sandy beaches and stunning vistas; it's also a treasure trove of exceptional pizza restaurants while you are there to unwind. Prepare to embark on a delightful journey with me as we uncover the top 12 pizza spots that define Pawleys Island's culinary landscape.

Pizza Paradise: Unveiling Pawleys Island's Top 12 Pizza Havens

Whether you are looking for great food to satisfy your taste buds for the whole family with whole pies, great people and great service with welcoming Southern vibes in a beautiful dining space, or a happy hour special and good pizza after a long day relaxing on the sandy beaches of Pawley's Island you cannot go wrong with these options.  Friendly staff await at these locally owned pizzeria serving hand tossed pizza menu items at reasonable prices.  Come join where the neighborhood gathers or enjoy pizza delivery during your next Pawleys Island SC visit and stay.

12 Great Pizza Restaurants in Pawleys Island SC:

1. Rosie's Pizzeria - This pizza restaurant in Pawleys Island is sure to become a favorite for the whole family with the full menu of appetizers, subs, signature pizza options after the first bite.  Open Monday-Saturday 11am-8pm, this ocean hwy pizza joint is one of the best restaurants when looking for a family restaurant.  Phone Number: (843) 314-3730 to order.

2. Rustic Table: With a cozy ambiance and a wood-fired oven at its heart, Rustic Table elevates pizza-making to an art form. Their inventive combinations and dedication to quality and finest ingredients make every slice a taste sensation using local ingredients in every legendary pizza and meal they serve. I highly recommend making a reservation any Tuesday-Sunday at this delicious restaurant.  

3. Gio's Pizza: A family-owned gem, Gio's Pizza serves up authentic New York-style pies that never disappoint. From the perfect crust to generous toppings, their pizzas are a testament to classic flavors.

4. Landolfi's Bakery & Deli: Beyond their delectable baked goods, Landolfi's offers Sicilian-style thick-crust pizzas that embody comfort and flavor. Their focus on traditional recipes ensures a hearty and satisfying dining experience.

5. Pastaria 811: While pasta may be their forte, Pastaria 811's pizzas are equally impressive. Each pie is a masterpiece, meticulously crafted to deliver a harmonious blend of flavors.

6. Pawleys Prime: This upscale steakhouse surprises patrons with its delectable pizzas. Using high-quality ingredients and a touch of sophistication, Pawleys Prime offers a unique take on this beloved dish.

7. Island Bar & Grill: Known for its laid-back atmosphere, Island Bar & Grill presents pizzas that perfectly complement their beachy vibe. From classic favorites to innovative combinations, there's something for everyone.

8. Pawleys Island Tavern: Beyond its cozy pub ambiance, Pawleys Island Tavern crafts pizzas with a homemade touch. Generous toppings and a welcoming atmosphere make this spot a local favorite.

9. Rustic Pizza: As the name suggests, Rustic Pizza captures the essence of homemade goodness. Their pizzas, baked to perfection, embody simplicity and flavor in every bite.

10. Gio's Italian Kitchen: Another establishment by the Gio's family, Gio's Italian Kitchen offers a slightly different take on their renowned pizzas. Expect traditional recipes with a touch of innovation.

11. Franco's NY Pizza - Franco's NY Pizza was a popular eatery known for its authentic New York-style pizzas. They prided themselves on using high-quality ingredients and traditional recipes to recreate the flavors of classic New York pizzas. The menu typically included a variety of pizza options, from traditional cheese and pepperoni to specialty pizzas with diverse toppings.

    In addition to their pizzas, Franco's often offered other Italian-American favorites such as calzones, pasta dishes, salads, and appetizers. The restaurant aimed to provide a casual and welcoming atmosphere, making it a popular spot for families, locals, and visitors alike.

12. Massey's Pizza - today Columbus is the pizza capital of the world and most pizza shops in this area use the Massey’s cut rather than the pie cut. As a family-owned business, Massey’s has been winning the hearts of Columbus pizza lovers from one generation to the next. Massey’s has a secret dough recipe, baked on the hearth, with abundant toppings including: old world tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, aged provolone, Massey’s exclusive Guido Brand Portofino Pepperoni, house made Italian sausage, and Italian meatballs. A unique blend of ingredients and fresh ground spices has given Massey’s the “Perfect Pizza Taste”.  The great menu items including: stromboli, spaghetti, lasagna, specialty salads, and over 20 varieties of Jersey style subs, grinders, hoagies, and cheese steaks. Throughout every location, you will find great tasting food backed up by exceptional customer service. This tradition of excellence still guides the company today. If you consider yourself a connoisseur of great pizza or just a serious pizza lover, you owe it to yourself to try world famous Massey’s Pizza. 

There is a Pawleys Island Domino's Pizza joints, Marco's pizza, nearby pizza hut, papa john and there is a mellow mushroom in nearby Murrells Inlet. While these pizza places may be available, you will find the best pizza at the 12 delicious pizza locations above!

Pawleys Island is situated about 25 miles south of Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. The drive typically takes around 30 to 40 minutes, depending on traffic conditions. The two locations are connected primarily by US-17, making for a relatively straightforward and scenic coastal drive between the two destinations making it a great spot to visit if you are in the Myrtle Beach or grand strand area, trust me you will not regret stopping by and exploring the beautiful Pawleys island area of South Carolina. 

Pawleys Island's pizza scene is a testament to culinary diversity and excellence, where each restaurant contributes its unique flavors and styles to this beloved dish. Whether you're in search of a traditional Neapolitan pie or craving inventive toppings on a thin-crust masterpiece, this coastal town has something to satisfy every pizza craving. As you savor the flavors and soak in the hospitality of these top 10 pizza havens, you'll discover that Pawleys Island is not just a coastal retreat but a pizza paradise waiting to be explored.

This blog post provides a comprehensive guide to Pawleys Island's top 10 pizza restaurants, offering a diverse array of flavors and experiences for pizza enthusiasts visiting the area for the first time or returning to this great place in a family-friendly environment.